Open Floor Plan Versus Traditional: Which Is Better?

Open concept versus traditional floor plans has been a hot debate for the past couple of decades. As home renovation shows took off, it seemed everyone was knocking down walls. But after living in those spaces for a while, many people realized walls were not so bad after all. Here are the pros and cons of each.

Open Concept Floor Plans

An open concept plan typically combines the living room, kitchen and dining area into one large space without walls. In an older home, beams or columns can replace existing walls to open things up.

Pros

• Feels larger and more connected. The whole home feels more unified.
• Great for entertaining. The cook is part of the action, and guests can mingle easily.
• Easy to keep an eye on kids from the kitchen or dining area.
• More natural light from every direction keeps the space bright and airy.
• Strong resale appeal. Many buyers still prefer an open layout, though the split is closer than it used to be.

Cons

• Harder furniture placement because spaces are not clearly defined.
• Higher heating and cooling costs, especially with tall ceilings. When opening up an older home, plan your HVAC system and vent locations carefully.

Traditional Floor Plans

A traditional layout defines rooms with walls connected by doorways, doors and archways.

Pros

• Better for intimate conversations, even if it is less suited to large groups.
• Contained cooking smells and mess. You can enjoy your guests and deal with the dishes later.
• More privacy and quiet. No more hunting for a quiet spot for a phone call or escaping the TV noise.
• Ideal for working from home, which has renewed demand for defined spaces.

Cons

• Some see it as old-fashioned, and it is less ideal for large gatherings.

Finding a Middle Ground

Many homeowners choose a blend: an open kitchen and family room with a defined dining room, office or den. Wide cased openings and arches can connect rooms while still giving each its own identity.

Choose What Fits Your Lifestyle

Trends come and go, so choose what makes the most sense for how you live. If you have a large family or love hosting big parties, an open concept may be right for you. If you prefer intimate dinners and quiet places to retreat, a traditional layout may be better. See more in our post on the pros and cons of open floor plans.

Not sure which is right for your home? Call Tracy Tesmer Design and Remodeling at 678-450-1700 or contact us online.

This article originally appeared in Lakeside News.