How to know if it’s ‘island time’ in your kitchen

Tammy Doyle • April 22, 2022

Share this article

With kitchens growing larger and open concept spaces becoming more popular, it seems as if the kitchen island has become an essential part of many homes. However, that does not mean every kitchen is the right fit for a kitchen island.

If your kitchen is on the smaller side a peninsula or even a mobile island may work best for your needs. While a kitchen island can be nice for extra seating, it can also hinder function if your kitchen doesn’t allow space for one.

If you are trying to decide whether an island is the right decision for you, consider some of these reasons why you should go “island-free.”

Disruption in Room Flow

An island may disrupt the flow of your kitchen. It may disturb the “work triangle” concept. This is where the three most visited spots in the kitchen make up the three points of a triangle – sink, refrigerator and stove. This age-old concept is meant to maximize flow and efficiency. Kitchens are now more thought of as having zones. These zones really depend on how each family utilizes the spaces within their kitchen which is why we at Tracy Tesmer Design/Remodeling like to make our kitchen remodels as unique as the client themselves. If adding in an island doesn’t flow with how you work in the kitchen then it may not be the best fit.

The standard recommendation is for a kitchen to have at least 42 inches of space between the base cabinets and the island. A home with multiple cooks in the kitchen should consider 48 inches of space in between. You may be wondering why there needs to be so much space, but it’s because a kitchen island is meant to be a working area. If adding a kitchen island will become a nuisance in your space, then there is really no need for one. You don’t want the heart of your home to feel cramped and overwhelming. So, don’t force an island to fit if it’s not in the best interest of your space.

Instead, you could add a narrow, long table or a peninsula in your kitchen to still add more counter volume while keeping the center of your kitchen open and spacious.

Visually Weighs Down Your Space

Having a giant island in the center of your kitchen can become pointless if it isn’t being used regularly. Sometimes, these large islands become a space for dumping, piling and adding more clutter into your kitchen. Kitchen counters are already a hassle to keep clean with all the daily activities that can go on within this space. If adding another large counter area will just create a cause for more cleaning, then why add one. Or decide on a portable island that can easily be pushed to the side of the room when necessary, which allows you to use the space in several different way maximizing functionality.

A lot of times keeping a space simple can make it appear larger than it actually is. Don’t feel the need to visually weigh down a smaller kitchen by adding an island just because it seems to be on trend. The kitchen often feels like the heart of the home. It brings family together and must allow space for it to be lived in. Before deciding on a kitchen island, think about how you use this space and if an island will aid or hinder your interactions within the kitchen.

Is it Within Your Budget?

Adding a kitchen island will vary in cost depending on what you want it to include. Things to consider that can quickly add to the price tag include cabinetry, countertops, appliances, plumbing and electricity if you’re wanting to add a sink or stove top. Consider your budget before deciding whether to move forward with a kitchen island. It may add an unnecessary layer of costs to your remodel when an island is not particularly needed.

Remember – every kitchen is unique! While you may be able to renovate your kitchen to replicate one you loved when you saw it on your favorite home design show or magazine, certain features may not actually fit your space or lifestyle. Design-build experts like the team at Tracy Tesmer Design/Remodeling will meet with you, walk your current space and discuss your list of “must haves” for your new kitchen.

Considering remodeling your kitchen? The professionals at Tracy Tesmer will be happy to discuss options for kitchen islands and beyond that will keep your kitchen fresh and functional. Call today!

More about kitchen remodeling

Recent Posts

By Tammy Doyle April 13, 2026
As a homeowner, you might wonder how often you should remodel your home to ensure it stays functional, beautiful, and aligned with your needs. The answer isn’t the same for every household; various factors, including your home’s condition, your family’s lifestyle, and even local climate conditions, impact this decision. Let’s explore what determines the ideal […] The post How Often Should I Remodel My Home? appeared first on Tracy Tesmer Design|Remodeling.
By Tammy Doyle February 14, 2026
2026 Home Remodeling Trends in North Georgia: Designing for Health, Wellness, and Everyday Living As homeowners across North Georgia are rethinking how their homes support their health, comfort, and lifestyle, remodeling trends are moving beyond aesthetics and focusing on wellness-centered design, improved indoor environments and spaces that promote relaxation and movement.  From Gainesville and Cumming […] The post 2026 Home Remodeling Trends in North Georgia: Designing for Health, Wellness, and Everyday Living appeared first on Tracy Tesmer Design|Remodeling.
By Tammy Doyle February 2, 2026
2026 Home Design Trend: Outdoor Living Spaces That Support Health & Wellness By Tracy Tesmer Design/Remodeling As homeowners look ahead to 2026, one home design trend continues to rise above the rest: outdoor living spaces designed specifically for health and wellness. No longer limited to patios and grills, outdoor areas are being thoughtfully remodeled into […] The post 2026 Home Trends appeared first on Tracy Tesmer Design|Remodeling.
By Tammy Doyle January 20, 2026
A well-designed commercial space plays a critical role in how a business operates and how it is perceived by customers, clients, and employees. For businesses throughout Hall County and the surrounding North Georgia area, commercial remodeling offers an opportunity to improve functionality, modernize interiors, and better support daily operations. Whether updating an existing layout or […] The post Commercial Remodeling Solutions for Functional and Professional Business Spaces appeared first on Tracy Tesmer Design|Remodeling.
By Tammy Doyle January 16, 2026
2026 Home trend by TTDR.docx The post 2026 Home Trend appeared first on Tracy Tesmer Design|Remodeling.
By Tammy Doyle January 13, 2026
As more families in North Georgia choose to live under one roof, the need for well-designed, multigenerational homes has never been greater. Creating a living environment where grandparents, parents, and children can all thrive requires thoughtful planning, flexibility, and an understanding of how daily life unfolds for every age group. Addressing these needs during a […] The post Remodeling for Multigenerational Living: Design Ideas That Work for Every Age appeared first on Tracy Tesmer Design|Remodeling.
By Tammy Doyle January 6, 2026
Modern home remodeling is evolving quickly, and today’s homeowners are looking for more than just stylish finishes. Integrating smart home features during a renovation is an excellent way to enhance comfort, convenience, and long-term value. The demand for programmable lighting, automated climate control, smart security systems, and voice-activated technology is rising, especially as more families […] The post Smart Home Features to Incorporate in Your Next Remodel (Lighting, Climate, & Security) appeared first on Tracy Tesmer Design|Remodeling.
By Tammy Doyle September 29, 2025
Common Home Renovation Mistakes Home renovations can be exciting, but they also come with potential pitfalls if you’re not properly prepared. 1. Inadequate Planning One of the most common mistakes homeowners make is inadequate planning. Before beginning any project, clearly define your goals and expectations. While the professionals at Tracy Tesmer Design/Remodeling can assist with […] The post Home Renovation Mistakes and Tips appeared first on Tracy Tesmer Design|Remodeling.
By Tammy Doyle September 2, 2025
Create a Functional Basement Workspace People are working from home than ever before and having a dedicated, well-organized workspace is essential for maintaining productivity and work-life balance. If your home is short on space, your basement may be the perfect hidden gem. With a bit of planning and creativity, you can transform it into a […] The post Transforming Your Basement into a Functional Home Office: Design Tips and Ideas appeared first on Tracy Tesmer Design|Remodeling.
By Tammy Doyle July 31, 2025
Importance of Lighting in Kitchen Design The lighting you choose for your kitchen can dramatically change the mood of your home. There have never been so many options and different lighting styles to choose from as there are now. Whether you’re cooking, entertaining, or just enjoying a cup of coffee, the right lighting enhances functionality, […] The post The Impact of Lighting on Kitchen Design: What You Need to Know appeared first on Tracy Tesmer Design|Remodeling.
Show More